GUIDE
My son is only 8 and already has a shelf full of sports trophies, and his siblings are just starting. What do we keep, and how do we let the rest go without hurting his feelings?
By the seenow! teamLast updated:
Give each child one shelf and let them choose what stays on it at the end of every season. Photograph your child holding each trophy that leaves the shelf, note the team and year, then pass the rest on with the name plates removed. The child decides; the shelf sets the limit.
WHY
Why this happens
Youth sports start early and stack up fast. In the Census Bureau's report A Child's Day, 37.0 percent of children aged 6 to 11 played sports in 2023, and the share was 39.7 percent for ages 12 to 17. Many kids play more than one sport a year, and in many recreational leagues every child on the team gets a trophy or medal at the end of the season. Two or three kids, two or three seasons each, and the shelf fills in a few years.
Sports are also back in full swing. The same report shows participation climbing from 35.5 percent in 1998 to 39.4 percent in 2020, falling to 28.5 percent in 2021 during pandemic shutdowns, and returning by 2023 to about where it was before. For families with younger siblings just starting T-ball or soccer, the pile is only getting bigger.
What makes it hard is that a trophy stands for a season, not just an object. Kids may care about one from a team where they made friends and not at all about one from a league they quit. Parents often guess wrong in both directions, which is why letting the child choose works better than sorting while they're at school.
| Kind of trophy | What usually works |
|---|---|
| Your child's current favorite, or one tied to a big moment | Stays on their shelf |
| Every-player trophies from past seasons | Photo with your child, then pass on |
| Medals | Hang on one hook or ribbon rack per child |
| Broken or unclaimed ones | Take apart and recycle what your local program accepts |
HOW TO
What you can do starting today
Give each child one shelf, and let it be the limitNo app needed
Decide the space before you decide the trophies. One shelf per child, in their own room, is easy to explain: when it's full, something has to come off for something new to go on. That turns the question from "Should we throw this away?" into "Which ones do you want to show?", which kids find much easier to answer.
Sort at the end of each season, with your child choosingNo app needed
After the last game, when the new trophy comes home, sit down together at the shelf. Ask your child to pick what stays. You can suggest that older trophies rotate off as new ones come in, but let your child make the final call. Younger siblings can follow the same routine from their first season, so it feels normal rather than like a cleanup.
Take a photo of your child holding each trophy that leavesNo app needed
Before a trophy leaves the shelf, take a picture of your child holding it, wearing the jersey if it still fits. Add the sport, team name, season and coach in the photo's caption or file name. Keep these in one album per child. Years later, the photo of a 6-year-old with a gap-toothed grin and a gold plastic soccer player will mean more than the trophy in a box would.
Pass the rest on with the name plates removedNo app needed
Pry or peel off the engraved plates and keep them in an envelope if your child wants them. Then ask around before tossing anything: your league, a local trophy shop, a teacher who runs an adapted PE class, or a thrift store. Not every place takes used trophies, so call first. What's left can be taken apart; check which parts your local recycling program accepts. EPA counts only an 8.7 percent recycling rate for plastic in 2018, with 27 million tons going to landfills that year, so reuse is worth a phone call.
WITH SEENOW!
Doing it with seenow!
seenow! can't store trophies, but its camera is handy for the photo step and for grandparents who missed the season.




- The seenow! camera shoots with the front and back cameras at the same time, so you can capture the trophy and your child's face in one post. A 2-second clip of them telling you what they liked about the season works too.
- Post it to a family group with grandparents you invite, so they can see the end-of-season moment from far away.
What seenow! can’t do
- Only photos and videos taken with the seenow! camera can be posted. Trophy photos you already took with your phone's camera can't be added, so keep your main trophy album in your phone's photo library.
Core features are free.
POINT
Things to watch for in this situation
Don't sort while they're away
Finding a missing trophy can upset a child far more than choosing to give it up. Even if it takes longer, sort with them, and take things out of the house when they are not watching.
Keep the shelf limit for every sibling
If one child gets two shelves, the others will notice. A rule that is the same for everyone is easier to keep than deciding each case.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Should we keep participation trophies at all?
Keep the ones your child cares about. Many kids are proud of their first-season trophy even if every player got one. The rest can be photographed with your child and passed on.
Where can I donate old sports trophies?
Try your child's league, a local trophy shop, teachers who run adapted PE or reward programs, and thrift stores. Remove the name plates first, and call ahead, because many places don't accept used trophies.